D3 · Presidents' Athletic ConferenceNon-conference
Tartans' climb up the ratings sets up a test for Bearcats
St VincentAway65
Carnegie MellonHome77Carnegie Mellon has climbed 43 spots in the Versus ratings since the preseason, a rise built on defense: the Tartans carry an A+ defensive grade, 7th in Division III, even though the offense only grades out as an A-. St Vincent has moved the other direction, dropping 59 spots since the preseason despite sitting at 2-2 and having won its last two games.
That form has been loud. St Vincent's 106 points against St Francis PA in its most recent game were its most since January 2025, and the Bearcats followed an 11-point loss to Case Western with back-to-back blowout wins. Carnegie Mellon counters with its own statement, a win over John Carroll, a team ranked 33 spots ahead of the Tartans' own No. 52 in Division III, and the Tartans have outscored their last five opponents by an average of 15.4 points while going 4-1.
Versus ranks Carnegie Mellon 149 spots ahead of St Vincent in Division III, and projects a 77-65 win for the Tartans at home in a non-conference game. St Vincent did win the teams' most recent meeting in December 2025, 78-76, so an upset would not be unprecedented.
Graded within D3, 406 teams